Term limits squashed like a bug

By John Christian Hopkins
Diné Bureau

WINDOW ROCK — Shonto Delegate Jonathan Nez knew his council term limit bill faced an uphill battle — but he didn’t expect an avalanche of opposition.

“I bring this legislation as previous recommendations by our Navajo people. This legislation is a community-based or grassroot recommendation,” Nez said during the second day of the winter session Tuesday. “Talking with many people throughout the Nation they have mentioned that different perspectives need to be brought into the council. Term limits would give other people a chance to bring in new and up-to-date ideas into the council.”

Nez’ legislation would limit delegates to four consecutive terms — 16 years. After sitting out a term, delegates could then run again and serve another 16 years, he explained.

The speaker would be limited to four two-year terms, Nez said.

“This change would also fall in line with Navajo teaching of knowing one’s self in any position of leadership,” Nez said. “Doo naatanii jidindlaadah. Bah hastxi. The time of rest and realization of one self would occur for those who serve four consecutive terms.”

His bill wouldn’t affect current delegates, as it would not begin taking effect until the 22nd Navajo council, Nez explained. Any time served by current delegates would not count against them, he said.

“Let’s support change and give a glimpse to our Navajo people that we are capable of being open to new ideas,” Nez said.

Both the InterGovernmental Relations and Ethics & Rules committees voted against the legislation.

Most of those who spoke about this legislation Tuesday kept their comments in Navajo.

Under Fundamental Law, the people are free to elect their own leaders, said Public Safety Committee Chairman Rex Lee Jim.

“We need to respect that,” Jim said.

People can determine their own term limits when it’s time to vote, Delegate Edward Jim said. Candidates don’t run alone, there is a choice for the people to select from, he added.

“I’m a veteran. I believe in freedom, I believe in the Navajo people,” Edward Jim said.

“The majority of the council is not in favor if this document,” Government Services Committee Chairman Ervin M. Keeswood Sr. said. “I think it would be pointless to sit here and repeat ourselves.”

Nez’ bill was defeated by a 26-46 margin.

But the loss didn’t dishearten the first-term delegate.

“There are some delegates who believe in change,” Nez said, pointing out that 26 other delegates supported his measure.

John Christian Hopkins can be reached at hopkins1960@hotmail.com